All articlesRisk and sizing

Spread filter for signal copying

A copier places a signal at whatever the broker quotes. A maximum spread stops a trade opening when the quote is stretched. Here is how to pick the limit and test it.

A spread filter for signal copying is a ceiling on the spread you accept when a copied trade is placed: if the broker's spread is wider than your limit at that moment, the trade is not opened at that price. CopySignals is a cloud Telegram signal copier for MT4, MT5 and eTrader: it reads the rooms you already follow through your own Telegram account and places the trades on your own broker account, and a maximum spread is one of the controls it gives you per account.

What is the spread, and why does a copier care?

The spread is the gap between the price you can sell at and the price you can buy at. MetaQuotes describes the two sides in its MetaTrader 5 help: "Buying is executed at the demand price (Ask), and Sell is performed at the supply price (Bid)". The difference between Ask and Bid is the spread, and you pay it the moment a position opens. A buy at 2,650.00 on gold with a 0.30 spread starts life 0.30 under water against the bid.

A person placing a trade by hand looks at that number without thinking about it. A copier does not look at anything unless you tell it to. A signal arrives, the copier reads it, and the order goes out at whatever the broker quotes. Most of the time that is fine. The rest of the time the quote is unusual, and the trade is placed anyway.

When does a wide spread hurt a copied signal?

The damage is largest on small targets. Take a scalping room that posts a first target 40 points from entry. If your broker's normal spread on that pair is 10 points, a quarter of the first move goes to the spread. If the spread is 30 points because the market is thin, three quarters does. The signal is identical and the trade is a different trade.

Spreads can be wider around a scheduled news release, and your broker's own quotes will show you when. Signal rooms do not schedule around that. They post when the analyst sees a setup, and a setup often forms exactly when the market is busy. A stop loss that is 20 points away and a spread of 25 points is a trade that can be stopped out by the quote alone.

How does a maximum spread work in CopySignals?

You enter the widest spread you will accept, and trades are opened only while the spread is at or under it. The setting sits with the other controls on the copier, next to symbol renames, word filters, an instrument list, a delay before placing, a cap on open positions and reverse copy. All of them are in every plan.

The limit is set per account. A funded account with tight drawdown rules can run a strict limit while a personal account at another broker runs a looser one, and each broker quotes its own spread. Gold, an index and a major pair also have very different normal spreads, so look at what your own broker shows for each instrument you copy before you choose the number.

We do not state a default because your broker decides what normal looks like. The right way to choose the value is to watch the spread column in your terminal for a few sessions and set the limit somewhat above the ordinary reading, not at it. A limit set at the ordinary reading blocks trades on every small flicker.

Spread filter or delay before placing: which one?

They answer different questions, and CopySignals has both. The spread filter asks whether the price is acceptable right now. The delay before placing waits a chosen time after the signal arrives. Around a news release the two can work together: the delay lets the first jump settle, and the spread limit stops a trade from opening if the quote is still stretched when the delay ends.

Neither one is a substitute for sizing. If you size a trade by percent of the account against the signal's own stop, the arithmetic uses the stop distance the room gave, not the spread you actually paid; the working is in our article on lot size from risk percent. On a wide spread, the real loss at the stop is a little larger than the percent you chose. Cap the lot as well, so that a bad quote cannot also produce a large position.

What does the spread filter not do?

It does not make a trade better. It only decides whether to open it now. It does not judge the room, and a signal that is skipped because of spread is a signal you did not take, which you may regret if the price then runs to the target. That is the trade-off and it belongs to you.

It also cannot change what the broker does after the order is sent. A quote can move between the moment the copier checks it and the moment the broker fills the order. A spread limit reduces bad fills, it does not remove them, and it does not remove slippage either. Trading carries risk, and a filter is a way to shape it, not to take it away.

And it applies to accounts you connected on MT4, MT5 and eTrader. Accounts on other platforms cannot be connected, so there is nothing to set a filter on.

How to test your limit before real money

  1. Connect a demo account from the same broker as your live one, so the spreads match. Spreads differ between brokers and sometimes between account types at the same broker.
  2. Note the ordinary spread on each instrument the room trades, at a quiet time and again near a news release.
  3. Set the maximum spread above the ordinary reading and copy the room for a week at the smallest lot.
  4. Read the event log for each signal that was not placed and compare it to what the price did afterwards. If most skips were fine, keep the limit. If it blocked normal trades, raise it.

While the demo runs, you can set up break even and partial close too, so one test covers the whole trade.

Is a spread filter more important on a prop firm account?

Usually, yes, because the loss limit is fixed and the account is not yours to top up. A few bad fills on a funded account can use the daily allowance that a personal account would shrug off. We cover the per-account controls in copying to several prop firm accounts, and the rules that matter before you connect one in prop firm rules and trade copiers. Read your firm's own rules first, since they decide what a copier is allowed to do.

Gold is the instrument where readers most often run into this, because its spread moves more than a major pair's. Our piece on copying gold signals has the symbol name side of it.

Where to set it

Set the limit when you add the copier, along with the maximum lot, and change it after you have seen a week of real signals. Every plan has the whole product, from Starter upwards, so the filter costs nothing extra; the plans are on the pricing page, with a 30 day money back guarantee. If your rooms trade Telegram signals on MT5, the Telegram to MT5 page has the setup steps. Start with a demo account and a limit a little above the normal spread.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

A spread filter is a limit on the spread a copier accepts when it places a trade. In CopySignals it is called the maximum spread and is set per account.
Watch the spread your broker shows on each instrument you copy for a few sessions, then set the limit a little above the ordinary reading. CopySignals does not pick a value for you, because every broker quotes differently.
No. The price can move between the check and the fill at your broker. A maximum spread reduces bad fills but cannot remove them.
Yes. Every CopySignals plan includes the whole product, with a 30 day money back guarantee.

Copy the rooms you already follow, on your own account

Connect your Telegram and your MT4, MT5 or eTrader account once. The copier runs in the cloud, so nothing has to stay on at home. Every plan includes the whole product.

Cancel in one click.